Home
 
Quick Tour Break Out Room Login
 
HR buddies

The Covent Garden HR Buddies is an initiative facilitated by Clarkslegal to offer the London HR community the opportunity to meet with like-minded peers, attend relevant seminars and workshops and boost your knowhow of the issues specific to this sector.
 
It’s free and open to anyone interested in HR. It sets its own agenda, so it can be purely social or facilitate presentations to help prevent HR problems for companies in the London area. So if you want to network face to face contact
buddy@clarkslegal.comClick here for further details about our next HR Buddies event.  

If, alternatively, you wish to network online with other HR professionals, then using the discussion forum below, is your ideal opportunity to do so.

Please feel free to post new queries or questions, and/or reply to ones already posted. All you have to do is register a few details, then you will be ready to post your thoughts.

You can post a new query by selecting the tab "new thread". To reply to a post, select that post and then choose the "reply" tab.

Discussion zone
SearchForum Home
     
  Discussions  Buddy's question time  Promotion prosp...
 Promotion prospects
 
creynolds
127 posts
5th
Joined
12/12/2006

Promotion prospects
Posted: 19 Nov 07 2:11 PM Modified By creynolds  on 11/19/2007 2:11:41 PM)
This week buddy was asked:  One of my employees takes a long time to produce written work and the finished articles are often full of mistakes.  He is in a group of employees currently being considered for promotion.  However, I am reluctant to promote this individual owing to the problems with his written work.   It has been suggested that he is dyslexic and I am worried about the implications of overlooking him.  What steps should I take to ensure fairness in this situation?
creynolds
127 posts
5th
Joined
12/12/2006

Re: Promotion prospects
Posted: 27 Nov 07 12:57 PM

Buddy says: Dyslexia may be a disability under the Disability Discrimination Act 1995 (DDA). As a result, employees are protected from less favourable treatment due to their dyslexia, and you may be required to make reasonable adjustments to their working arrangements to remove any disadvantage that they may suffer.

 

Therefore it is important that this be discussed sensitively with the employee, with a view to obtaining a medical report to assess whether the employee is dyslexic, and if so, take reasonable steps to avoid any disadvantages they may face.

 

Awards of compensation for discrimination are uncapped and it is therefore important that you have the employee assessed as soon as possible, before decisions regarding promotions are made.

 

Employer information: If the employee does in fact suffer from dyslexia, and the reason you do not promote him is influenced by the problems with his written work, then not to not promote him is likely to be discriminatory.  The DDA defines discrimination as less favourable treatment on grounds of the Claimant's disability.  The less favourable treatment in this scenario would be the lack of promotion. In other scenarios, the relevant treatment could be the recruitment process, where the dyslexia could affect an applicant if all applicants were required to complete written work for the job application.

 

Disability in the DDA is defined as a physical or mental impairment having a "substantial and long-term adverse affect on ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities".  As writing is an activity that is undertaken on a regular basis it is likely that this may be a normal day to day activity.

 

When looking at whether the effect is substantial you should look at the effect of the condition on the employee, rather than by comparing their ability with the population at large.  Therefore, if the dyslexia is causing the employee numerous problems with written work it may be viewed as substantial.

 

You should also be aware of your duty to make reasonable adjustments that will stop the employee being treated less favourably. This could involve him completing his written work on computer with a spell checker or other such software. This could then mean that as well as complying with your duty to make reasonable adjustments you can promote the employee without worrying about the standard of his work.

 

If it transpires that the employee does not have dyslexia, and it is just the case that the employee is careless and makes mistakes, then this can be considered as normal when looking at reasons for and against promotion.  Also, in this situation you could invite the employee to a capability meeting to discuss his performance and explain how the quality of his written work is hampering his chances of promotion.  This will give him a chance to build on this constructively and improve his standards.
  Discussions  Buddy's question time  Promotion prosp...
 
Clarkslegal LLP is a limited liability partnership registered in England and Wales. Registered number: OC308349. VAT registration number: 198 9098 84. Registered office: One Forbury Square, The Forbury, Reading RG1 3EB. Solicitors regulated by the Law Society. References to Partners are to members of Clarkslegal LLP. Clarkslegal LLP is a member of the TAGLaw worldwide network of law firms. * Trade Mark Applied.