Human resources at a click

“Self-employed” hairdresser found to be employee

women-looking-at-financial-documents-with-a-calculator

The Claimant, a hairdresser, sought to pursue claims for unfair dismissal, notice pay, holiday pay and redundancy pay following the closure of the salon in which she worked but the Respondent argued that because she was self-employed the Tribunal did not have the jurisdiction to hear these claims.

At a Preliminary Hearing to determine her status, the Judge found the Claimant was in fact an employee for the following reasons:

  • The Respondent had a very high degree of control over the Claimant, including over:
    • the days and times she worked;
    • the clients she saw, the services provided and the amount to charge; and
    • The clothes she wore and the products she used.

The Claimant, a hairdresser, sought to pursue claims for unfair dismissal, notice pay, holiday pay and redundancy pay following the closure of the salon in which she worked but the Respondent argued that because she was self-employed the Tribunal did not have the jurisdiction to hear these claims.

  • It was clear that the Claimant was obliged to accept the work allocated to her and the Respondent was obliged to pay her for it; and
  • Despite the existence of a substitution clause, the Claimant could not send someone of her own choosing to work in her place and would not be paid unless she provided the services personally.

This ruling is a strong reminder to employers that when assessing employment status, the Tribunal will pay particular attention to the reality of the working arrangements.

Disclaimer This information is for guidance purposes only and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking professional and legal advice. Please refer to the full General Notices on our website.
Anonymous author

Related Articles

Specific Performance and Injunctions ‘Specific performance’ is a type of equitable remedy available, in some circumstances, and at the court’s...

The Government has recently announced a new right to neonatal leave and pay to be introduced from 6 April 2025....

We reported previously on the new statutory code of practice which should be used in ‘dismissal and re-engagement’ scenarios otherwise...

Related Resources

Jury service factsheet

The document briefly outlines the jury service process. Background An individual who is summoned must make himself available to serve...

Sustainable workplace HR policy

Sustainable workplace HR policy outlining environmental performance and developing a more suitable workplace. The Company accepts that its activities have...

Employee handbook

Template employee handbook with rules and instructions for employee. The purpose of the Employee Handbook (“the handbook”) is to provide...

Human resources at a click